Landlords Are Using Utility Bill Loophole to Raise Rents and Evict Tenants

by Madison Alvarado : sfpublicpress – excerpt

Alleged failure to pay opaque, inconsistent bills on time can be weapon to evict tenants illegally, housing attorneys say.

Imagine you are a senior living on a fixed income. On top of paying rent and a steady Pacific Gas & Electric bill, you pay your landlord nearly $200 a month for other utilities.

Instead of charging for individual usage, your landlord divides costs among all the units — possibly including landscaping and building-wide plumbing issues — using a special formula. Your sewage costs alone can rise to $100 a month, going beyond the 5% limit specified in your lease.

That is the reality for a Parkmerced resident who described the hardships created by an increasingly common billing system in communications to California Attorney General Rob Bonta and the San Francisco City Attorney’s Office…

The San Francisco City Attorney’s Office and the San Francisco Rent Board declined interviews for this story. Jen Kwart, communications director of the City Attorney’s Office, wrote in an email that “RUBS are on our radar, and we encourage any tenants or community organizations aware of systemic illegal practices by landlords to submit a complaint here.”…

The legality of using ratio utility billing systems for tenants in rent-controlled units is questionable. Multiple eviction defense attorneys said these systems violate rent control laws because utility costs paid to the landlord fluctuate beyond the annual rent increase limits set by the Rent Board. Thornton said the Eviction Defense Collaborative has successfully challenged several such evictions… (more)

The pandemic forced a reinvention at China Basin. Then Sierra AI moved in

By Kevin V. Nguyen : sfstandard – excerpt

McCarthy Cook doubled down on the waterfront complex as tenants fled, transforming a tired office into a destination for companies of the next tech boom.

For the two decades in which he’s been managing the China Basin development for landlord McCarthy Cook, Richard Hayes had been pitching his bosses on the idea of connecting the property “to the water.”

The office complex at 185 Berry St. sits on the channel just across from Oracle Park, but its two buildings face each other inward, and the only way to see or reach the water is through the back doors of the wharfside building.

Before the pandemic, since the buildings were fully leased, there just wasn’t much incentive for the landlord to do any remodeling, Hayes said.

Then came the great exodus, which cut occupancy at the nearly 1-million-square-foot property to 30%. “The design we had was good for that era,” Hayes said. “But we had to move beyond our comfort zone if we were going to compete again.”

In 2021, J.P. Morgan, which owns a majority stake in China Basin, agreed to pay for the kind of large-scale renovation Hayes had been pushing for. The owners considered several concepts, including splitting the property into vertical sections, “townhome style,” before settling on a plan to turn the ground floor of one building into a waterfront destination rather than a walkway.

Five years later, that vision has come to life with Water’s Edge(opens in new tab): a cafe, coworking space, lounge, and event venue that is open to China Basin tenants and members of the public. Sergeant Ma, a new fine-dining Asian fusion restaurant and bar with waterfront views, ties it all together…

Hayes’ wish for China Basin to go “to the water” isn’t quite complete though. The only thing missing from Water’s Edge is a dock. The team has a license but not the funding… (more)

This provost is possible to use existing buildings without tearing anything down. We hope to see more of these re-model projects and less tear-down to build new projects. Nothing about this project obstructs the neighbors or the neighborhood.

GASHOUSE COVE, LAST CHANCE TO FIX RPD’s PLAN

Thursday November 5th, the plan for Gashouse Cove will pass its last regulatory hurdle.  On that day, BCDC will hold a public hearing and vote to approve the permit for RPD’s project which will effectively make it final.

More details on the subject and a different a request for a full EIR: https://sites.google.com/mhpv.net/savepublicaccesstoboating?usp=sharing

The plan is bad, but, There is a chance to improve it but that will only happen if enough people reach out to BCDC now.

Some of the issues have been resolved. The idea of a boat harbor in front of the Marina Green was soundly defeated, but there are still an issues of the toxic chemicals in the water spilling into Gashouse Cove from a large drainage pipe.

There are two main problems with the plan, We are requesting a couple of changes in the draft explained below.

  • Rec and Park Department (RPD) wants to turn the area into a “shallow-water basin” for public access for paddleboards, kayaks and other non-motorized vessels, in shallow water that is polluted from the drainage pipe which is not the safest option, but, that is what they want to do.
  • RPD also wants to decommission the only fuel dock in San Francisco in Gashouse Cove. Numerous first responders came forward to explain how important fuel availability in this part of the Bay is to their work. Because it’s so crucial, the Harbor Safety Committee wrote a letter to BCDC urging it to act on the matter.

RPD responded by saying the Port will build a new fuel dock at Hyde Street Harbor. Our concern is timing. We want the fuel dock be built prior to closing the old one. To fix that problem we suggested a couple of changes detailed in the draft email below.

What is the status?

Staff has finalized their recommendation, it will be heard and voted on November 5th.  Commissioners almost always approve staff’s recommendation but they are capable of, and sometimes do, adding or deleting elements during the hearings. This is the only chance to fix it.  

What can be done?

There are three ways to provide input:

  • Send an email before 10 am on November 4th to publiccomment@BCDC.com mentioning the project’s name, “MIRP.”
  • Attend the hearing in-person. The meeting will begin at 1pm at Metro Center, 375 Beale Street, San Francisco.  Gashouse Cove is item #8 on the agenda.  A reasonable guess is the topic will begin after 1:45pm and last about 2 hours. Or,
  • Attend the hearing virtually. Information is available at https://www.bcdc.ca.gov/event/november-5-2026-commission-meeting/
  •  Look for the Zoom and WebCast links at the top of the page.  Instructions for providing input can be found under “Learn How to Participate” at the bottom of the page.

Ask the BCDC commissioners, not staff, to take specific action at the November 5th hearing to improve the plan.


SUGGESTED EMAIL suggesting edits to the MIRP:

To: publiccomment@BCDC.com

SUBJECT: MIRP – Gashouse Cove is item #8

Dear Commissioners:

Given the current weather considerations that are already threatening to flood the Marina Green and nearby neighborhoods soon, we urge the Commission to reject approval of Agenda Item 8 and require a new, independent Environmental Impact Report (EIR) based on a 19-year-old EIR for a fundamentally different proposal.

If you do feel obliged to rush forward and deny the request for an EIR, at least approve these these additions to the approval of the MIRP presented on November 5 :

  • A minimum depth of 8’ MLLW shall be maintained for beneficial use throughout Gashouse Cove, both North and South, at all times.
  • The existing fuel dock in Gashouse Cove shall not be decommissioned until a nearby replacement fuel dock is operational for use by all vehicles, public and private, that are called upon to react to emergency conditions on the bay and the Pacific ocean.

We appreciate your time and attention to this matter.

Thank You.

(name)

Five Decisions That Could Shape San Francisco’s Westside

By Danita Kulp : westsideobserver – excerpt

From the Great Highway to City Hall, a neighborhood perspective on the November ballot

The November election asks San Franciscans to think about more than individual candidates or propositions. It asks what kind of city we want to live in, how we balance competing needs, and whether neighborhoods have a meaningful voice in decisions that affect daily life. From my perspective on the Westside, five questions deserve particular attention.

  1. The Great Highway: A Road, a Park and a Neighborhood Divide
  2. District 4: What Does Neighborhood Representation Look Like?
  3. The Congressional Race: Experience, Judgment and Accountability
  4. Proposition D: How Hard Should It Be to Put an Issue Before Voters?
  5. Ranked-Choice Voting: Understand the Rules Before You Mark Your Ballot… (more)

Ninth Circuit Hands Newsom Final Win Over Trump’s National Guard Takeover

By Eileen Vargas : hoodline – excerpt

According to a statement from Gov. Newsom’s office, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of Newsom and the State of California in the lawsuit filed by Attorney General Rob Bonta on behalf of the governor and the state against President Trump. California Attorney General Rob Bonta, who is based in Oakland, took to social media Friday to celebrate the outcome, writing that the Ninth Circuit had made clear that President Trump’s 2025 deployment of California’s National Guard was unlawful and unconstitutional… (more)

Kansas City is no place for the Bay Area’s National Archives. They belong here

By Harry Mok : sfchronicle – excerpt

In July, news broke that the National Archives and Records Administration was planning to close its San Bruno facility and relocate key artifacts that detail the history of Chinese immigration to the U.S., including a file on Bruce Lee.

The agency stayed mum about details of the move until last week, when it announced in a letter to San Mateo Rep. Kevin Mullin where the San Bruno archives will go: Kansas City, Mo.

No offense to Kansas City, but the Bay Area is where these archives belong…

California Attorney General Rob Bonta concurs. He filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court on Wednesday to block the relocation.

Bonta argued in the lawsuit that the move would “irreparably harm California and its interests” and that “transferring the records and artifacts would not only take them away from the communities that rely on them most, but also would risk damage and loss of the items altogether, given their age and fragility.”

The suit alleged that the National Archives and Records Administration is violating the Administrative Procedure Act and claimed the agency did not “act to preserve public access to archival material and consider the public’s interest when making decisions.”.. (more)

We understand that the National Archivist see the national election results before anyone else, making this a highly sensory issue as far as the elections are concerned. Hopefully some journalists will look into this and raise an alarm.

Lurie’s Gift to the Bayview: Another AI Data Center

by Dr. Ahimsa Porter Sumchai & Glenn Rogers, RLA : westsideobsesrver – excerpt

San Francisco wants to lead America’s AI boom. Dr. Ahimsa Porter Sumchai warns that District 10 residents could be left with the pollution, power demands and environmental risks.

ayor Daniel Lurie’s proposal to site another high-megawatt AI data center in District 10—at a time when communities across the nation are pushing back against data centers in vulnerable neighborhoods—is a political mistake with potentially profound human consequences.

It is particularly troubling given that District 10 Supervisor Shamann Walton has called for a moratorium on new data centers.

quote marks

City residents don’t have to look any further than Bayview-Hunters Point to see the link … the specific area where data centers are located has a pollution burden of 6.8, but its diesel pollution is among the worst in the state, according to OEHHA data.” San Francisco Examiner

San Francisco’s AI Boom Has a Physical Address

Since 2024, San Francisco and Silicon Valley have emerged as a “major node for high-density tech infrastructure” and one of the nation’s largest regional AI data-center hubs, according to DataCenters.com.

Micro Center’s America’s AI Cities  analyzed the 100 largest U.S. cities using factors including AI-related jobs, startup activity, data centers, internet access and search interest. It ranked San Francisco first among America’s AI cities.

According to DataCenterMap.com, 15 active data centers currently operate in San Francisco proper, an estimated 32 operate in the immediate vicinity of the city, and approximately 150 operate in the regional triangle extending from San Francisco through Alameda and Santa Clara counties…

The Sound of AI Never Stops

Data centers warrant scrutiny as heavy industrial uses for several reasons. Chief among them is noise… (more)

How real estate investors are profiting off a California tax break for affordable housing

By Kate Talerico : sfchronicle – excerpt

The Meridian apartments in San Rafael look out on yacht slips and million-dollar homes. But tenants who have lived in the 1960s gray stucco complex over the years — most of them low-income immigrants from Guatemala and El Salvador — have come not for the view but to claim a rare working-class foothold in wealthy Marin County.

So when the Meridian’s new landlord said it wanted to convert the building to affordable housing, tenants were hopeful their rent would go down.

Instead, they learned, some rents would go up.

The conversion would be a better deal for the building’s owner, San Francisco-based private equity firm Tesseract Capital Group. The company could substantially avoid property taxes through a California law known as the welfare exemption — all without meaningfully lowering rents…

The Meridian is one of hundreds of apartment buildings across the state that major investors — from Apollo Global Management to the California State Teachers’ Retirement System — are converting into affordable housing to take advantage of a quirk in housing law. In some places, affordable rent limits tied to area median income are so high that landlords can charge market rate and still qualify for a tax break.

As a result, the welfare exemption, meant to keep housing affordable, has instead become a tax avoidance strategy in which owners save hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars a year without giving tenants a discount on rent, a Chronicle investigation found…

“Affordable” rent limits exceed market rents in most California metros

Difference between the maximum rent allowed under California’s welfare tax exemption for a one-bedroom and market rent… (more)

“Priscilla’s law” requiring ebikes and electric scooters to be registered and have license plates

nysenate (excerpt)

Senate Bill S2599A

2025-2026 Legislative Session

Relates to enacting “Priscilla’s law” requiring ebikes and electric scooters to be registered and have license plates.

2025-S2599A (ACTIVE) – SUMMARY

Requires bicycles with electric assist and electric scooters in a city with a population of one million or more be registered with the department of motor vehicles and have a license plate affixed to such bicycle with electric assist or electric scooter… (more)

RELATED:

At Packed Hearing, N.Y.C. Lawmakers Debate How to Slow Down E-Bikes

Lawmakers on Wednesday reviewed a record number of proposals to regulate the use of electric bikes and scooters, after a series of fatal crashes…. (more)

AB-1857 Unlawfully restrictive covenants: grocery stores and supermarkets.

Some relevant points in AB-1857 authored by Assembly Member Aguiar-Curry, (Principal coauthor: Assembly Member Wicks) (Coauthors: Assembly Members Bonta, Kalra, and Schiavo):

(f) Restrictive covenants contained in deeds, leases, and other land use documents prohibit the use of commercial property for food retail purposes, preventing food retailers from establishing at a site, and therefore operating as private land use barriers that reduce food access, limit consumer choice, suppress competition, and create conditions for the high cost of food…

(h) Restrictive covenants in housing deeds, which were used to prohibit non-White families from owning homes, were rendered judicially unenforceable by the United States Supreme Court in 1948. California law now prohibits the enforcement of such covenants and requires their identification and disavowal in property records…

(j) It is therefore a matter of statewide concern to eliminate private land use restrictions that impede access to food. The Legislature finds that voiding restrictive covenants that prohibit or limit grocery and supermarket uses is a reasonable and necessary exercise of the state’s power to protect public health, promote equity, and advance the welfare of all Californians.

SEC. 2.  Section 714.8 is added to the Civil Code, immediately following Section 714.7, to read: 714.8.  (a) This section shall be known as, and may be cited as, the Grocery Store Access Act… (more)

Comments: This is exactly what I was hoping for when I heard of the deeded covenants. I don’t know how this may help any of our current cases in SF, but it is good to know the covenants will not be able to impeded the use of the existing grocery stores or use of the property.

There could be additional challenges and amendments, ie: no grocery may be closed or demolished if such actions cut off food access to a community that relies on it.

Preserving Neighborhoods

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free